Catch of the Day Read online

  "So, what do you think, Malone?" Chantal asks. "You want to go out with Maggie?"

  By now, the whole bar is listening. Though I should be used to public embarrassment, my cheeks are burning. Malone drops his gaze to my chest, looks for a minute, then looks up at my face again. He shakes his head. The bar erupts in laughter. Chantal and Jonah clutch each other, shrieking, Stevie and Dewey high-five each other at Malone's insult, and I just sit there and nod my head.

  "Right," I say over the hysteria. "Well, I deserved that. Sorry, Malone. That was a crummy thing to say."

  He gives a slight nod, then turns to the beer that Dewey presents him.

  "Okay, I've embarrassed myself enough tonight," I say to my brother and Chantal. "I'm going home. Good night."

  "Bye, Maggot! Thanks for the laughs," Jonah says, sliding his arm around Chantal's shoulders. She blows me a kiss, then turns to say something to Jonah. My jaw clenches momentarily.

  I get my coat from the table and head out. At Malone's stool, I pause. "Sorry again," I murmur.

  He nods without looking at me.

  "I still owe you that pie," I remind him. He doesn't respond.

  Although I catch a glimpse of Malone once in a while at Dewey's or at the dock, I haven't spoken with him since he drove me to Joe's in the rain. He did a kind thing for me last spring, and tonight I insulted him.

  As I walk home through the quiet town, an unpleasant sense of shame keeps good pace beside me.

  CHAPTER FIVE

  A FEW DAYS LATER, whatever shame I felt has faded to a distant prickle. Once again, the presence of Father Tim melts away all bad feelings, his beautiful smile simultaneously reassuring and thrilling.

  Last night, my parents had summoned their offspring to a family dinner, something they insist on about once a month or so, and much to my delight, Father Tim was invited, as well. As I showed Colonel to his doggie bed in my old bedroom, I could hear Father Tim laughing downstairs, the rumbling voice of my dad, Violet's happy, ear-splitting shrieks. It seemed so natural.

  We had a very nice dinner and a lemon cake that I'd baked in honor of the occasion. Father Tim had two pieces. "Maggie, you're a genius, you are, my girl," he said, finally pushing back from the table. I smiled sappily, heart fluttering.

  Talk turned to the inevitable--my failure at finding a boyfriend. "Will, dear, can't you find anyone for Maggie?" Mom asked.

  "Apparently not," Christy intoned, nudging her husband, who looked rightfully chagrined.

  "It's not funny, Christy," Mom said sharply. "She's never going to meet anyone behind that counter. Think of how you're going to end up, Maggie! A spinster waitress like Judy."

  "I like Judy," I answered weakly. Mom likes to go right for the kill.

  "Now, Lena," Dad said meekly. I knew it was no use. There was no stopping my mother on this subject. No daughter of hers was going to be unmarried. Not if she had a breath left in her body!

  "Well, I just don't understand why it's so difficult," Mom said to Father Tim. "She's perfectly nice! Look at Christy! Did Christy have trouble finding a nice husband? No! So why can't Maggie do the same thing? Maggie, if only you'd get a real job, some place where you could meet some eligible men. Like Christy--"

  This comparison theme song, which I have mentally entitled "Christy is Better," is one Mom's sung many times. "Do you have to be so perfect?" I asked my sister.

  "Sorry," she sang, wiping mashed-up carrots from Violet's eyelid. "I really can't help it. It just happens."

  "--in my day, people wanted to get married," my mother was saying. "Now, of course, everyone's out there, doing all sorts of things. Why buy the milk when you can just rent the cow for free?"

  Jonah shot me a quizzical look--Mom's never been good with cliches--then mooed softly at Violet, who banged her spoon on the highchair tray in approval. Jonah mooed again, this time in my direction.

  "I have a great idea," I said. "Let's pick on Jonah! Jonah, why haven't you given Mom any grandchildren yet? What's the matter with you? Don't you have unprotected sex anymore? Don't you care about your own mother?"

  "Maggie!" Mom admonished. "There's a priest in the room! Father Tim, I don't know where she gets this trashy talk."

  But Father Tim was laughing, as I knew he would be. "I've no doubt that Jonah conducts himself like a gentleman," he said. "Furthermore, Jonah, my man, I trust that you've given thought to--"

  "Actually, Maggot, thanks for reminding me," Jonah interrupted blithely. "I've got a date. Thanks for dinner, Ma."

  "Wait, honey, I have some leftovers for you," Mom said, pressing a huge plate into his hands.

  "Goodbye, you spoiled little prince," I said, allowing him to kiss my cheek.

  "Goodbye, you dried-up old hag," he returned fondly. He turned to Christy. "Goodbye, beautiful, nice sister. Goodbye, filthy little baby."

  "You put me in mind of my own family," Father Tim said. He looked a little sad, and I took the opportunity to pat his hand.

  "You must miss them so much," I commented.

  "I do, Maggie. I do." He patted back, and a shameful heat flowed up my arm to my heart.

  After Violet was tucked into her portable crib, my parents broke out the Trivial Pursuit. "Three teams," Dad announced. "The Mrs. and I are undefeated, Father Tim, so we don't want to break our streak. Will, you can be with your lovely bride there, and Maggie, you won't mind showing Father Tim the ropes, will you, sweetheart?"

  Christy grinned wickedly. "I think we all know the answer to that," she murmured so that only I could hear.

  "Have you gained a few pounds?" I asked. "They look good on you."

  And so the rest of the night was spent quipping and insulting and laughing. Really, how could I not imagine Father Tim and me together? Maggie O'Halloran. What a great-sounding name!

  The next day, I'm sitting in the rectory living room, having dodged the Gorgon Plutarski, who guards Father Tim like a pit bull protecting a steak. I stare at Father Tim's beautifully shaped mouth and idly rub a patch of eczema on my knuckle. Tonight is the big spaghetti supper to raise money for a new roof on the western side of the church, which started leaking after a nor'easter last winter.

  "The final count is closer to sixty people," Father Tim says. He leans forward, clasping his hands together loosely. The scent of his soap drifts to me, and I try not to swoon. For God's sake, Maggie. Literally. For God's sake. He's a man of the cloth-- "Do you have enough? I hate to be putting this on you on such short notice, but apparently we had a few last-minute reservations."

  "Oh, no problem," I say. It's so cozy in this small living room, Father Tim sitting just across from me. I swear, I could look into those eyes for the rest of my life....

  "Can you do the bread, as well, Maggie? I'm sorry it's so late, my asking, but it completely slipped my mind."

  "Hmm? Oh, the bread? Sure. No problem."

  "Ah, thank heaven for you, dear girl," he says, though he is only a year older. "You're a treasure."

  A jewel, a treasure, darlin'... I know he calls everyone by those pet names, but still. We were so natural together last night, playing couples' Trivial Pursuit, sharing huddled discussions over whether the answer was Eisenhower or Nixon, David Bowie or Iggy Pop...

  I stand up, trying to shake myself mentally. Get over him, Maggie, I instruct myself. I need to stop. I really do. I want to. I'm going to. I sound like a drug addict. Perhaps there's a twelve-step program for me. Priest Lovers Anonymous.

  In the rectory office, Mrs. Plutarski pauses in her phone conversation to shoot me a suspicious glare. I ignore her and walk out into the frigid rain.

  Sighing, I glance down the street. The familiar weight of loneliness presses down on me. The spaghetti dinner is hours away, the diner is closed. If only I had that nice guy I've imagined... The sweet, hardworking one with the easy laugh and dancing eyes. It's a great day for cuddling, and while Colonel is excellent at cuddling, he's not exactly the same thing as a hubby. No, Colonel could lie in front of a warm, snapping f
ire as my husband and I sat cuddled up on the couch, reading, drinking coffee...

  My thoughts are cut off as a Hummer growls down the street, plowing through an enormous puddle. A sheet of muddy, icy water slaps down on me, drenching and punishing. "Hey!" I yelp. The vehicle slows at the library, pulling into a parking space near the front door.

  "Asshole," I mutter. Fully intending to march down the street and tell them they're idiots, I find myself slowing down. A woman, dressed in a cheerful red raincoat and matching hat, gets out of the passenger's side. She opens the back door and out pop three blond children wearing colorful raincoats and brightly colored boots. The mother extends both hands, and the smaller children each take one, the oldest kid running ahead to hold the door for his mother and sisters. Even from a half a block away, I can hear their laughter.

  I guess I won't tell them off. They're not idiots, after all. As a matter of fact, they look like an ad for clean American living, aside from the earth-defiling vehicle they drive. They look like the kind of family I'd like to have someday. The woman seems like the kind of mother I'd want to be: laughing, well-dressed, unconsciously affectionate, automatically protective.

  Then the driver's door opens and out gets Skip Parkinson.

  His presence is like a punch to the stomach, so silent and stunning that I actually bend over. I haven't seen him since the day he dumped me, that awful day when he brought his fiancee back home.

  Skip glances down the block, and though I knew him immediately, it's clear he doesn't have that same instinct for me, despite having just soaked me through to the skin. My teeth begin to chatter, but I don't move, just watch as Skip casually jogs into the library, still full of easy, athletic grace.

  Skip must be visiting his parents. No doubt the lovely, adorably dressed children got antsy being stuck inside, so Skip and Mrs. Skip took them to the library to get a book or a movie that would occupy them for the rest of the day. No doubt Skip and Mrs. Skip will return to the Parkinsons' lovely home on Overlook Street and cuddle and read on the couch, the fire crackling, their legs entangled.

  That could have been me in the bright red raincoat, being driven through the cold rainy afternoon by Skip, my husband. Those cheerful, handholding kids might have been mine.

  Turning around, the cold rain slicing my face, I race home. It's only three blocks, but I run as fast as I can, and by the time I get there, I'm gasping. I pound up the stairs, hoping that Mrs. K. doesn't decide she wants a chat or a pedicure, and burst inside. The only sound is of my rasping breath and the rain drumming on the roof.

  Colonel hauls himself out of his dog bed and woofs softly. I kneel down and hug him, burying my face in his beautiful fur. "Oh, buddy, I'm so glad to see you," I say. "I love you, Colonel."

  When an eighty-five pound mammal licks your tears away, then tries to sit on your lap, it's hard to feel sad. I give my dog some chicken breast to reward him for his love, then go to the bathroom and stare at myself in the mirror. Bad idea. Bedraggled, wet hair sticks to my face, which is blotchy with cold. My mouth is grim.

  I slam my way out of the bathroom and go to the cupboard above the fridge--the rarely-used liquor cupboard--and take out the unopened Irish whiskey given to me by a nice old man who died about five years ago. I used to bring him dinner on Wednesday nights. Mr. Williams. Nice guy. I slosh about six ounces into a glass and raise it. "Here's to you, Mr. Williams," I say, drinking. Yuck. I grimace hugely, shudder, then take another swallow.

  Grabbing the phone, I call the bakery in Machias and order eighteen loaves of Italian bread, then call Will, who is at the hospital up there today, on his cell.

  "Will, can you do me a favor?" I ask abruptly.

  "Sure, Maggie, sure. You okay?" he asks.

  I tell him about the bakery order, remind him to come to the spaghetti supper. He is happy to pick up the bread. Great guy, that Will. I drink to him, too. "And here's to you, Colonel Love Pup," I say, raising my glass to my dog. He wags his tail and rests his head on my foot.

  I look at the clock. 3:09. Octavio closed today, and is probably already home with his wife and five kids. I hope he remembers to bring the two huge pots of homemade sauce and twelve dozen meatballs I left on the diner's stove. That's how I spent my morning, from 4:00 a.m. until seven. Cooking for a church event, even though I don't go to church. That's our Maggie, anything for Father Tim. Nothing else to do, right? It's not like anyone's home waiting for her.

  By the time I leave my apartment, I'm feeling a bit more cheerful. I trip off the curb and step into a frigid puddle up to my ankle, but it's okay. Weaving over to the church, I flip on the lights in the echoing basement and get out the big pasta pots. "You are the sunshine of my life," I sing, glad that Stevie Wonder can't hear me. "That's why I'll always stay around, oooh, oooh, yeah, yeah..."

  Over the past year, I've become well-acquainted with this kitchen. I've cooked corned beef on St. Patrick's Day, mulled cider for the carol sing, boiled eggs for the Easter egg hunt. Here I make huge pans of lasagna for after-funeral gatherings, throw together blueberry cakes and cookies for bake sales. Coffee hour? No problem...I donate the scones, set up the beverages, fill the creamers. My home away from home, this kitchen. "You're such a loser," I tell myself. My voice echoes through the basement.

  I fill the huge pots with hot water, throw in some salt and turn on the gas. Then, feeling a little bit dizzy, I decide to lie on the floor and wait for the water to boil. It's nice on the floor. Cool and smooth. My back aches a little, and I stretch, then close my eyes. A brief nap, perhaps, before everyone comes.

  "Hey, boss." The voice floats to me over the counter. Octavio and his wife come in, each carrying a giant vat of sauce, followed by their many children.

  "Oh, hi!" I say. "Hello! How are you? It's nice to see you, Patty. Hello, Mookie. Hello, Lucia. Hi, other kids! Hi!"

  "You okay, boss?" Octavio asks, giving me a questioning look.

  "Yes. Yes, I am. I am A-okay. Thank you," I answer. Perhaps I should get up? I do, groping for a handhold on the counter and hauling myself unsteadily to my feet. "And you? How are you lovely people?"

  "We're fine." He and his wife exchange a look, then set the sauce down and go back to the van for the meatballs. The kids start running around, playing hide and seek. I turn the sauce on low and notice the bottles of wine under the counter. That's right--this is a wine event. How nice! Not just another boring spaghetti supper--a nice wine dinner. That's nice. It's nice to have wine. "You kids are nice," I announce to the Santos children as I uncap a bottle.

  The oldest girl, Marie, who is seven, stops running. "Thanks, Maggie," she says, smiling shyly. "You're nice, too."

  "I know," I say. I wrinkle my nose and smile at her. What a nice girl.

  An hour later, the place is full and conversation bounces around the basement like a hundred ping-pong balls. I must not think about that, or it will make me woozy. And I'm already very busy trying to conceal the fact that I might be a little tipsy. Every movement must be carefully planned, every phrase prethought. My parents come over, looking the nice part of the nice parents they are.

  "Hello, Maggie. This looks very pretty," Mom says. She glances at the tables we set up, the little fake flower centerpieces. In order to avoid that prison-cafeteria feel that so many church events have, we've turned on only the recessed lighting, not the fluorescents.

  "Thank you, Mom. You are so nice to say so," I say. "Hi, Dad. It does look nice. Not like prison. Like a nice place. Like a church."

  Luckily, Mom is scanning the room for someone for me to marry. "Maggie, are you... Have you been drinking?" Dad asks quietly.

  "A little," I admit. It's hard to keep both eyes focused right now...the left eye seems to be wandering. I squint it shut so it will stop bothering me.

  "Have you had anything to eat today?" Dad asks.

  "Hmm. Yes. I had a sour cream cranberry muffin this morning, and let me tell you, Daddy, it was freaking fantastic."

  "Okay, baby, let's get you f
ed." Dad, good old Dad, steers me to a table and pushes me into a seat.

  "Can't I sit with Octavio?" I ask. "I love that guy!"

  "Stay here," Dad says. "I'll be right back."

  It's nice, staying here. I'm glad I have to. But the room is spinning just a little, so I put my head on the table. It's like being on a carnival ride...I can feel the movement, but with my eyes closed, I don't have to see.

  Someone sits next to me. "Hello," I say without lifting my head. "Welcome to the dinner."

  "Are you drunk?" It's my sister.

  "Mmm-hmm. Daddy's getting me some food." I lift my head. Oops. I'm drooling. There's a wet spot on the table. I grab the flowers and place them on the splotch, then turn to face Christy. "Hi."

  "Whoa," she says. "What happened?"

  It doesn't seem prudent to mention the whiskey I drank earlier. "Oh, I don't know...I think I had a glass of wine on an empty stomach. Thash all. Jushta li'l wine." I smile to cover the fact that I'm slurring.

  Dad returns with some salad, bread, a glass of water and a bowl of pasta that could feed a family of four. "Eat, sweetie," he instructs. "And Christy, can you run interference with your mother? She's over there talking to Carol."

  "Sure," she answers. She stands up and pats me on the shoulder.

  "I love you!" I call, waving to her. "You are so sweet, Christy."

  I eat the food--it's delicious, I have to say--and begin to feel drowsy. Christy, Violet and Will come over with plates, and after a little while, Mom, too. Another family dinner. My eyelids droop, but Dad has me on the far end, away from Mom so she won't know her spinster daughter is now also the town lush. Maybe I can go lie down on the coat pile, I think. It looks so cozy. People mill around, going up for seconds. "Great food, Maggie," several people call, and I wave sloppily in response.

  Then I see Father Tim. He's chatting up Mr. and Mrs. Rubricht, laughing, clapping Mr. on the back. Mrs. Plutarski, his self-appointed bodyguard, preens in her proximity to the priest. Preening proximity to the priest. I chuckle. "Preening," I say out loud. Dad turns to me, concerned, but I can't take my eyes off Father Tim.

  He's so nice, Father Tim. We had so much fun the other night, didn't we? That man is a great guy. He's no asshole, not like Skip. Nope, Father Tim is my best friend. I love him.